In your answer demonstrate your knowledge of the relevant readings

  In your answer demonstrate your knowledge of the relevant readings and lecture material. You may use outside sources. 

 Judith Jarvis Thompson employs the “Unconscious Violinist” example (p. 103). Explain this example and its relevance to your reader. Don Marquis disagrees with Thompson (see page 123).  What is Marquis’s argument here? Who is right? Thompson or Marquis? Why? (If the answer is ‘neither’, give reasons).